History Told by Chester

Anaheim Turned Down a Real Monorail Twice

Anaheim was offered a real monorail twice in the 1960s, and it said no twice. Both offers came from the same man, and both would have linked Disneyland to Knott’s Berry Farm.

The monorail Anaheim already had

Disneyland’s monorail opened on June 14, 1959. In that first form it was an attraction. It had one station and a scenic loop that brought you back to where you started.

In 1961 it became real transportation. The track was extended outside the park to a second station at the Disneyland Hotel. You could now board in one place and get off in another.

That is as far as it ever went. The line has not been extended since.

1963: six miles to Knott’s Berry Farm

In late 1963 a company called Duorail Aerospace Rapid Transit Corp., or DART, proposed a six-mile monorail between Disneyland and Knott’s Berry Farm. The company was headed by a man named Earl J. Welch.

DART needed one thing from Anaheim. It wanted the city to sponsor a federal grant to help finance the line. Sponsoring a grant does not mean paying for the monorail. It means applying for the money.

Anaheim declined. The city’s stated reason was that it did not want to take federal funds.

The record we worked from does not give a price for the 1963 line or any franchise terms. For the first proposal we know the route, the man, the request and the answer.

Los Angeles said no in 1963

Anaheim was not the only place turning down a monorail in those years. On June 4, 1963, Sixten Holmquist of Alweg Rapid Transit Systems offered Los Angeles a privately financed monorail. Los Angeles rejected it.

Alweg was Disney’s partner on the Disneyland monorail, which opened as the Disneyland-Alweg Monorail System, so it is easy to fold that offer into the Anaheim story. It does not belong there. It was a different city and a different proposal. The Los Angeles Metro library’s history of the Anaheim proposals does not mention Alweg at all. Those were DART in 1963 and, three years later, a second company with the same man in charge.

1966: the same man, with private money

Earl J. Welch came back in 1966 with the Anaheim Rapid Transit System, or ARTS. This plan was bigger. It was a monorail loop linking Disneyland, Knott’s Berry Farm, Anaheim Stadium, the Anaheim Convention Center and several business hubs.

It also answered the objection from 1963. The second time, he asked the city for no public money at all. ARTS would be financed with private capital, at costs quoted as high as $3 million per mile. The city would help only with acquiring rights-of-way. In return, ARTS would pay Anaheim 1% of its gross receipts after seven years.

Welch wanted a 99-year exclusive franchise. The city council endorsed only 40.

Then the city studied it. After several months, Anaheim concluded that a monorail was not urgently needed. It put its money into bus and jitney service instead.

What it looks like when a city says yes

Our video has no picture of either Anaheim proposal. The period footage in it shows two real monorails: Disneyland’s, and the one in Seattle. Wherever you see a beam running down a city street, that is Seattle.

Seattle is the nearest thing to a look at the road Anaheim did not take. Alweg raised pillars up the middle of Fifth Avenue there in 1961 and opened a line through downtown for the 1962 World’s Fair, three years after Disneyland’s monorail opened. Photographs from June 1961 show the pillars going up in the street. That line is still running.

Anaheim got its buses. The monorail at Disneyland still ends where it ended in 1961.

What we left out

This story is often told with these. We could not source them, so here is what we said instead.

  • Alweg proposed the Anaheim monorails

    It is not documented. Alweg was Disney’s partner on the Disneyland monorail, built Seattle’s, and made its own offer to Los Angeles. The Anaheim proposals were DART and ARTS.

  • Disneyland’s monorail was the proof of concept for them

    No source we found says the proposals cited it. They would have connected to Disneyland, and that is all we say.

  • The Disneyland beam was meant to reach into Anaheim

    Disneyland’s own track was never part of DART or ARTS. Both were separate lines proposed by an outside company.

  • What the 1963 line would have cost

    The record we used gives a per-mile figure only for the 1966 plan, and that one is a quoted upper figure, so we repeat it as quoted.

Sources: 10, including Los Angeles Metro, Dorothy Peyton Gray Transportation Library and The Monorail Society
  1. History of Monorail Proposals in Los Angeles and Southern California (opens in a new tab)Los Angeles Metro, Dorothy Peyton Gray Transportation Library
  2. LA’s Worst Transit Decision (opens in a new tab)The Monorail Society
  3. Monorail (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  4. Disneyland-Alweg Monorail System (opens in a new tab)Yesterland
  5. Disneyland Monorail System (opens in a new tab)ASME
  6. Disneyland Monorail (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia
  7. The Seattle Center Monorail: A Must-Do Two-Minute Ride Through Seattle History (opens in a new tab)Seattle Center Monorail
  8. Seattle Center Monorail (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia
  9. Category: Seattle Center Monorail (opens in a new tab)Wikimedia Commons
  10. Century 21 Calling (opens in a new tab)Prelinger Archives via the Internet Archive

26 photographs by 19 photographers. Full credits