History Told by Chester

Disneyland’s Keel Boat Tipped Over With Guests Aboard. It Never Ran Again

Disneyland

Disneyland’s Mike Fink Keel Boats ran for more than forty years and ended in one afternoon. On May 17, 1997, the keel boat Gullywhumper rocked side to side and rolled over with a boatload of guests aboard, and neither of the ride’s two boats ever carried another passenger.

Named for the man who lost

The keel boats opened on December 25, 1955, Disneyland’s first Christmas, on the Rivers of America in Frontierland. They came straight out of the Disneyland television show. That fall the show aired two keelboat episodes, “Davy Crockett’s Keel Boat Race” on November 16 and “Davy Crockett and the River Pirates” on December 14.

In the race, Davy Crockett beat Mike Fink, the “King of the River.” Davy won on television, but the ride carried Fink’s name for its whole run: Mike Fink Keel Boats. The two boats were the Gullywhumper, Fink’s boat in the story, and the Bertha Mae, Davy’s.

Boats from the set, then bigger ones

The first boats were the actual props from the filming, refitted with windows and benches for guests. That lasted about a year. According to Yesterland, the TV props were then replaced by purpose-built boats with fiberglass hulls, longer than the originals.

Guests rode in the cabin and packed up on the roof. The ride ran mostly in summer and on some busy weekends. In 1972 it was a “C” ticket, one step below the Mark Twain, the Sailing Ship Columbia and the canoes, which were all “D” tickets.

A little top heavy

The keel boats always rode a little top heavy, and AllEars has written of a few near-misses before 1997. In 2021 it published the memories of Ted Kellogg, a skipper in the 1960s who later ran the watercraft at Walt Disney World, about keeping a wobbly keel boat afloat. That is one skipper’s memory, and we have only the one source for it.

The gap in the 1990s

The boats went quiet once before the end. They closed at the end of summer 1994, stayed down through 1995 and came back in 1996. Disney’s own A to Z reference gives the reopening as March 30, 1996. Duchess of Disneyland notes that no official reason was given for the closure, and we have not found one.

May 17, 1997

According to Yesterland’s account, at about 5:30 in the afternoon the Gullywhumper began rocking side to side during the trip and capsized, putting the guests aboard into the river. Several of them had minor injuries.

The boat was pulled from the water for inspection. Neither keel boat ran again. Disney’s A to Z lists May 17, 1997 as the day the keel boats closed. There was no farewell season and no last ride.

We have to be plain about what we could not find. We found no newspaper report from 1997 online, and no photograph or film of the accident. The moving pictures in our video are home movies from 1958 and the 1960s, and they show the later fiberglass boats on ordinary days.

Where the boats went

Four years later, in December 2001, Disney sold the Bertha Mae through its online auctions on eBay for $15,000. The listing described her as “not actually a seaworthy craft,” meant for display on solid ground. The buyer was Richard Kraft, an agent for film composers.

The Gullywhumper came back in spring 2003, as scenery. She was moored at Tom Sawyer Island as a prop and slowly weathered there. When the Rivers of America was refurbished in 2010, she was redressed as a windowless 19th-century keelboat beside a cabin renamed Mike Fink’s Cabin, the old Burning Settler’s Cabin.

Walt Disney World’s Magic Kingdom had its own Mike Fink Keel Boats, with boats of the same two names. They ran from October 1, 1971 to April 29, 2001.

Davy won that race on television, and his name is still on the canoes on the same river. Mike Fink got the ride. It ended on a spring afternoon in 1997, with no last ride.

What we left out

This story is often told with these. We could not source them, so here is what we said instead.

  • Davy Crockett’s Keel Boats

    It is an easy mix-up, since the ride came out of the Davy Crockett shows. It was Mike Fink Keel Boats for its whole run, and the canoes are the ride with Davy’s name, so we use the ride’s real name.

  • A capsizing in 1994

    No source we found records a capsizing in 1994. 1994 was the year the boats closed for the season and stayed down until 1996, so we give the accident as May 17, 1997.

  • Disney closing it quietly

    We found no source that says Disney hid or declined to announce the closure, so we say only what the sources record: the boat went in for inspection and never came back out.

  • The particulars of the skipper’s story

    The AllEars article would not load for us, so we could not check its details, such as the size of the bigger boat or how the near-roll ended. We give only what its title and summary say.

  • The Gullywhumper today

    A photograph from 2021 shows a keel boat prop, but its page does not say which boat it is or where it sits, and we found no current source, so we stop at the 2010 refurbishment.

  • More detail on the guests

    One low-tier site gives a passenger count, and one account names where guests were treated. We could not confirm either from a second source, so we say minor injuries and stop there.

Sources: 10, including D23 and Yesterland
  1. Mike Fink Keel Boats (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  2. Gullywhumper (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  3. Bertha Mae (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  4. Davy Crockett’s Keelboat Race (television) (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  5. Davy Crockett and the River Pirates (television) (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  6. Yesterland: Mike Fink Keel Boats on the Rivers of America (opens in a new tab)Yesterland
  7. Mike Fink Keel Boats (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia
  8. Mike Fink Keel Boats: Frontierland Ride \[Closed\] (opens in a new tab)Duchess of Disneyland
  9. Mike Fink Keelboats: Magic Kingdom’s River Adventure (opens in a new tab)Extinct Disney
  10. That Sinking Feeling: How a Keel Boat Skipper Kept His Wobbly Boat Afloat, October 25, 2021AllEars

Footage and image credits