History Told by Chester

Pirates of the Caribbean Was Supposed to Be a Wax Museum

Pirates of the Caribbean was supposed to be a wax museum. In the late 1950s, the plan for Disneyland’s pirates was a walk-through museum of historical pirates, with wax figures standing perfectly still.

A museum of standing pirates

The idea goes back further than most fans expect. Fan historians trace sketches for it to 1957, by the artists Bruce Bushman and Duane Alt. A 1958 Disneyland map design by Sam McKim included a Pirate Wax Museum.

Picture it the way it was planned. You walk in on foot. The pirates stand along the way, every one of them frozen in place, and you walk past them and out the other side.

In 1961 the project went to Marc Davis, the Imagineer who would go on to give the ride its characters and its gags.

It got further than paper

The museum was not only drawings. According to one account, a huge hole was dug on the site, and concrete and steel were laid. That account says Walt had the steel ripped out when the concept became a boat ride.

We tell that part the way our video does, as one account, because it reaches us through one memory, Marc Davis’s, as the historian Jim Korkis recorded it. It is still a striking picture. Work had begun on a building made for walking, and Walt was willing to pull out what was already in the ground.

What the World’s Fair changed

After the 1964 World’s Fair, the museum became a boat ride. Disney’s work at that Fair, with “it’s a small world” among its successes, showed what a boat-ride system and moving Audio-Animatronic figures could do. The Fair gave the pirates a way to travel and a way to move.

We do not give a month or a year for the change. The record we have does not settle one, so we say after the Fair and leave it there.

Walt in the middle of it

Walt stayed close to the new ride. He previewed it on television in January 1965, and he walked the unfinished ride himself with Marc Davis. At WED in Glendale he rode a dolly through a mock-up of the Auction scene, pushed at the pace of a boat, and gave the team his notes.

That Auction scene mattered. It was the only scene fully mocked up with working figures before installation, and its Auctioneer was the most sophisticated figure in the show. One photograph in our video, from 1966, shows Walt inspecting plastic heads for the Pirates figures, according to its original caption.

The team around him filled the boat ride with people who could move. Marc Davis drew the characters and gags, Claude Coats laid out the ride, Blaine Gibson sculpted, Yale Gracey worked the effects and Alice Davis made the costumes. X. Atencio wrote the script and the song “Yo Ho (A Pirate’s Life for Me)”. He had never written a song before.

March 1967

Pirates of the Caribbean opened at Disneyland in March 1967. Today you float past the pirates in the dark, and they move.

A note on our pictures. Almost every photograph in the video shows the ride and New Orleans Square as they look today. None of them shows the wax museum plan. The 1963 aerial view in it shows the park years after that plan was drawn, and the 1966 photograph of Walt with the plastic heads comes from before the ride opened.

The pirates Walt first pictured would have stood still forever. By one account, the ground was opened for them, and they never came.

What we left out

This story is often told with these. We could not source them, so here is what we said instead.

  • How many figures the ride opened with

    Sources give different counts, so we do not give a number.

  • The exact date the plan changed

    We found no month or year we could stand behind, so we say after the 1964 World’s Fair.

  • Walt not living to see it open

    Walt died on December 15, 1966, 93 days before the ride opened. That story has its own video on our channel, so we leave it there.

Sources: 14, including MousePlanet and D23
  1. Disneyland 1967 Part One: Pirates of the Caribbean (opens in a new tab)MousePlanet
  2. Walt Disney and New Orleans (opens in a new tab)MousePlanet
  3. 6 Seafaring Facts about Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean (opens in a new tab)D23
  4. “Disneyland’s 10th Anniversary” Show on Walt Disney’s Wonderful World of Color (opens in a new tab)D23
  5. Legendary Disney Animator and Imagineer Francis Xavier “X” Atencio Passes Away at Age 98 (opens in a new tab)D23
  6. Alice Davis (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney Legends
  7. Walt’s Last Adventure: The 50th Anniversary of Pirates of the Caribbean (opens in a new tab)The Walt Disney Family Museum
  8. Pirates of the Caribbean Ride History (opens in a new tab)The Walt Disney Family Museum
  9. Surprising History of the Pirates of the Caribbean Disneyland Attraction (opens in a new tab)The Walt Disney Family Museum
  10. The Complete History of Pirates of the Caribbean at Disney Parks: From Redhead to Redd to Peg(-Leg Pete) (opens in a new tab)WDWNT
  11. Bruce Bushman: The Disney Years (opens in a new tab)America's Disneylands
  12. The Oldest Haunted Mansion (opens in a new tab)Long-Forgotten
  13. Pirates of the Caribbean (attraction) (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia
  14. File:Disney and pirate heads.jpg (opens in a new tab)Los Angeles Times, 1966, via Wikimedia Commons

Footage and image credits