History Told by Chester

Walt Redrew Tom Sawyer Island’s Outline Himself

Walt Disney redrew the outline of Tom Sawyer Island himself. He did it at home, in the red barn behind his house, on the night he decided the island his Imagineer had drawn was the wrong shape.

The shape on Davis’s desk

The island in the middle of the Rivers of America started as other people’s drawings. Imagineers Vic Greene, Herb Ryman and Claude Coats produced the first designs for it, working from Walt’s ideas. Marvin Davis then drew the island’s contours.

Walt did not like them. He did not rework them at the studio. He took the drawings home to the red barn workshop behind his house in Holmby Hills, and that night he spent hours reworking the layout.

The next morning there was tracing paper on Davis’s desk. Walt’s verdict came with it: “Now that’s the way it should be.”

One story, told by Davis

We want to be clear about where this comes from. The barn story is Marvin Davis’s. Bob Thomas told it, and Jim Korkis told it again in his book The Revised Vault of Walt, which the Walt Disney Family Museum quotes on its blog. MousePlanet quotes Davis saying that the general shape of the island, and the way it curves, was Walt’s idea.

That is several writers passing along one man’s memory. It is a good memory to have, because Davis was the one whose drawings got redrawn.

The names that never made it

An early sketch by Herb Ryman shows an island with places on it called Point Diane and Lilly Bay. They were likely named for Walt’s daughter and his wife. The same sketch has a feature called Three Falls.

None of the three made it onto the island that was built.

An island of trees and dirt

Then the island Walt had fussed over sat empty. When Disneyland opened in 1955, Tom Sawyer Island was there in the river, and it held trees, shrubs and dirt. Disney’s own A to Z reference says its attractions were built many months later.

A billboard promised the island would open on June 1, 1956. It opened on June 16, 1956, and the only way across was a raft.

The island kept changing after that. Yesterland reports that two of its play rocks, Merry-Go-Round Rock and Teeter-Totter Rock, were quietly removed over the years as safety standards changed. It does not say when. The same site says Castle Rock, another of the island’s rocks, picked up masts and barrels in 2003.

Pirates move in

On May 25, 2007, the island became Pirate’s Lair on Tom Sawyer Island, a tie-in to the film Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. Harper’s Mill became Lafitte’s Tavern. Injun Joe’s Cave became Dead Man’s Grotto.

The island closed with the rest of the Rivers of America in January 2016, during Star Wars construction, and reopened on June 16, 2017.

What our pictures show

Most of the pictures in our video show the island as it looked between 2007 and 2026. None of them shows it in 1955 or 1956. Our river footage is our own, filmed at Disneyland in 2024 from Fowler’s Harbor and from the deck of the Sailing Ship Columbia. We do not have a picture of Davis’s drawings or of the tracing paper Walt left on his desk.

Walt bent the shoreline into shape by hand, one night in a barn. Other people have decided what stands on it ever since.

What we left out

This story is often told with these. We could not source them, so here is what we said instead.

  • The only part of Disneyland Walt designed by himself

    You will see this said. It traces to Jim Korkis’s book, and the island’s design credit is shared with Greene, Ryman, Coats, Sam McKim and Davis. We say Walt redrew the outline himself, which is what Davis described.

  • That Walt worked all night

    The accounts say he worked that night, for hours. We kept to that.

  • When Fort Wilderness came down

    Sources disagree on when the island’s fort closed and when it was demolished. All we can say is that it was gone by 2007.

Sources: 8, including D23 and The Walt Disney Family Museum
  1. Tom Sawyer Island (opens in a new tab)D23 Disney A to Z
  2. Walt Disney’s Tom Sawyer Island (opens in a new tab)The Walt Disney Family Museum
  3. Farewell to Tom Sawyer’s Island (opens in a new tab)MousePlanet
  4. Yesterland: Castle Rock Ridge (opens in a new tab)Yesterland
  5. Mark Twain, Walt Disney, and the Playful Response to Pirate Stories (quoting Bob Thomas) (opens in a new tab)American Journal of Play
  6. Disneyland’s Rivers of America Closing Day Videos (opens in a new tab)TouringPlans
  7. Tom Sawyer’s Island Reopens Giving Glimpse into New Rivers of America (opens in a new tab)Laughing Place
  8. Tom Sawyer Island (opens in a new tab)Wikipedia

Footage and image credits